Prince Fielder

The numbers tell the story of sustained excellence cut short. Six All-Star selections and three Silver Sluggers anchored by that monster 2011 campaign in Milwaukee — 38 homers, 120 RBIs, and a .981 OPS that ranked among the best in baseball. His 117 career OPS+ proves he was consistently above-average despite playing in an era when offense was down from the steroid peak.

Fielder's legacy lives in the what-ifs. He averaged 35 home runs per 162 games over his career, a pace that would have delivered 500-plus had his body cooperated. Instead, we're left with one of the more heartbreaking early exits in recent memory.