Eddie Miller

Playing shortstop during baseball's dead-ball hangover, Miller was the gold standard defensively at the game's most demanding position. His consistency was remarkable: he appeared in over 140 games in seven different seasons, anchoring the middle infield for the Reds and later the Phillies with reliability that managers treasured above offensive output.

The All-Star voting reflected how much his peers valued defensive excellence. In an era when shortstops were expected to field first and hit second, Miller's 97 homers across 15 seasons actually represented decent pop for the position. His true legacy lives in those eight midsummer classics — a testament to being the best at what mattered most.